Which asus notebook for video editing?
I want to get started with video editing as a beginner. Since I'm often on the go, the choice of a notebook was inevitable. Now, in view of the processor and the RAM as well as the SSD, I also looked for the price category because of two devices (leave out the price difference for now, the decisive factors for me are the technical components and the associated comparison values):
asus Notebook 1:
ASUS VivoBook D712 AMD Ryzen 7 3700U 17.3 1TB SSD 16GB RAM
SSD hard drive capacity: 1TB
Graphics chip: AMD Radeon RX Vega 10 Graphics
Hard drive type: SSD (Solid State Drive) Model: D712-Ryzen7-1TB-16GB-W10P Processor: AMD Ryzen 7 3700U
Graphics processor: Integrated graphics
Processor speed: 4x 2.3GHz (Turbo 4.0 GHz)
https://www.ebay.de/...4576128877
asus Notebook 2:
ASUS GL753VD 17.3 "FHD GAMER i7-7700HQ, 1TB, 512GB SSD, 16GB Ram NVidia GTX 1050
GPU type: Dedicated graphics
RAM size: 16 GB HDD type: HDD + SSD
Hard drive capacity HDD: 1 TB SSD: 512GB
Processor speed: 2.80 GHz
Model: GL753VD 17.3 inch 1080 Processor: Intel Core i7 7th Gen. SSD hard drive capacity: 512 GB Gi graphics card: NVidia GeForce GTX 1050 with 4GB GDDR5 Ram graphics processor: AMD Radeon RX Vega 56 with 8GB HBM2 Ram
https://www.ebay.de/...2112956096
(Offer expired, I have a comparable offer)
Can the processor "boost" to temporary 4 GHz outweigh the disadvantages of the integrated graphics card in the first device? (the second device has a dedicated one)
what about the comparison of processors? The second device is "older"
the SSD has been upgraded for the second device. Can this have an impact on the compatibility and the execution of rendering processes, for example?
Perhaps someone can help me with that.
Frankly, neither of them. The first has a pitiful 32Wh battery and the second weighs over 3kg
Look for a notebook with a Ryzen 7 4800U or even 4800H. Are 8-core with SMT, on the other hand, the 3700U or 7700HQ see absolutely no country. The 4800U is e.g. In the https://www.lenovo.com/.../customize? (With 16GB RAM, 256GB SSD, FHD IPS and 57Wh) for ~ 780 euro. 1000 euro are due for the 4800H in the https://geizhals.de/...ml?hloc=de (+ approx. 40 euro for additional https://geizhals.de/...l?hloc=de), but there's also an RTX 2060, which helps enormously depending on the software
Excellent! Thank you sincerely for your detailed help! I'm aware that I'm not working with the two Asus in the upper segment of the possible. For me as a beginner, I would have oriented myself to hard facts such as the "real" i7 processor, 16gb, a passable SSD, since this seemed to me to be conclusive as an entry-level component. What would still be worth mentioning: 17 "Diagonals are actually essential for me. I can understand your objections. Do you think that - if the weight and the battery performance are not so important to me - I still get a solid start with the devices Would video editing work or does it fail because of the basic components of the two offers?
Do you think that if the weight and the battery performance are not so important to me, I would still be able to get a solid entry into video editing with the devices, or will it fail because of the basic components of the two offers? Best regards!
Yes. But then take a look at the Asus TUF A17. Roughly also in the price range, is 17 "and the Ryzen 5 4600H is also far stronger than the other two CPUs
